Louisiana truckers seek caps on damages after Operation Sideswipe staged-crash cases
The Louisiana Motor Transport Association says it will keep pressing state lawmakers to cap non-economic damages, end "phantom" medical damages and limit third-party funding of lawsuits, as the federal Operation Sideswipe prosecutions over staged crashes with 18-wheelers in New Orleans go on, Transport Topics reported.
Federal prosecutors in New Orleans have charged 63 people in Operation Sideswipe, a case over collisions allegedly set up with tractor-trailers and other vehicles to collect insurance money and lawsuit settlements. Most of the crashes happened between 2015 and 2020 in New Orleans East and Gentilly, often close to a truck stop, WVUE reported. Some defendants have been convicted and sentenced. For the rest, the charges are allegations.
On Oct. 15 a federal judge sentenced former personal injury attorney Danny Patrick Keating Jr. to 32 months in prison. He had pleaded guilty in 2021 to conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud and admitted paying an associate to stage 31 crashes with large trucks. Prosecutors said he represented 77 plaintiffs and collected about $1.5 million in settlements. He must repay $657,405, the ABA Journal reported. In March, a jury convicted two other personal injury attorneys in the case.
Renee Amar, executive director of the association, told Transport Topics that lawsuit abuse and insurance costs are the two biggest worries of Louisiana carriers, ranking above fuel prices. The group has 300 member companies, and 85% of them are small trucking firms, some with a single truck. Amar said prosecutions by themselves will not change the state's legal climate.
The American Tort Reform Foundation, which campaigns for limits on lawsuits, ranks Louisiana fourth on its 2025-2026 Judicial Hellholes list, behind Los Angeles, New York City and South Carolina. The report says Louisianans file insurance claims at a rate 200% above the national average, citing insurance regulators' data, and puts the state's average yearly car insurance premium at $3,618. Plaintiffs' lawyers spent $74 million on 1.37 million ads in Louisiana from January 2024 through June 2025, the report found.
Why it matters: Claims and verdicts in Louisiana courts feed the liability premiums carriers pay there. The LMTA wants damage caps and curbs on litigation funding in Baton Rouge; fleets based or running in the state should follow those bills.
Sources
- New Orleans attorney sentenced in staged 18-wheeler crash trialWVUE via WLOX, Oct 15
- Former New Orleans lawyer gets prison for staged crash schemeABA Journal, Oct 23
- Louisiana truckers push for reforms amid staged-crash trialsTransport Topics, Nov 18