Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms: Supreme Court revives truck crash suit against shipper and Walmart
The U.S. Supreme Court on Nov. 16 wiped out California rulings that cleared produce shipper Irigoyen Farms and receiver Walmart in a wrongful-death suit over a 2019 truck crash near Fresno. It told the state appeals court to look at shipper liability again in light of Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II.

The order in Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms (No. 25-1421) grants review, vacates the judgment and sends the case back to the Fifth Appellate District of the California Court of Appeal, according to the court's Nov. 16 order list. The justices did not rule on the merits. Christina Casarez sued after her daughter, Olivia Mendoza, was killed in September 2019 when a truck carrying produce from Irigoyen in Selma, California, to a Walmart distribution center in Nevada went through a stop sign and struck her car, FreightWaves reported. The driver, an independent contractor, was convicted of vehicular manslaughter and got two years in prison.
Irigoyen hired Royal Violet Logistics, which passed the load to SIO Logistics, which booked carrier Gold Coast Logistics Group; Gold Coast hired the driver, the petition says. Casarez alleges that Walmart's delivery terms pressured carriers and that Irigoyen loaded the truck and sent the driver on a 350-mile overnight run knowing he was exhausted. No court has decided whether those claims are true. A Fresno County judge dismissed both companies in September 2023, finding the claims preempted by the federal law that bars states from regulating carrier prices, routes and services (FAAAA). An appeals court agreed in September 2025, and the California Supreme Court declined review in January 2026.
In May the Supreme Court decided Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, which lets negligence suits against brokers go forward under the law's safety exception. The petition argues the California courts relied on reasoning Montgomery rejected. Walmart said the order gives it the relief it asked for and that it will keep defending the case in the state appeals court. In its brief, Walmart said it did not pick the broker, the carrier or the driver.
The justices left open whether shippers and receivers, which the statute does not name, can claim FAAAA protection at all. Shippers have won so far since Montgomery: days after it, a Texas court rejected a claim against Home Depot over a fatal crash involving a Werner truck, FreightWaves reported. Gregory Reed, a transportation lawyer at Hanson Bridgett, told the outlet that federal appeals courts have not yet split on shipper liability, a split that usually comes before the Supreme Court takes up a question.
Why it matters: If the California court lets these claims go to trial, shippers and receivers could face the same crash suits brokers now face. That may change how they choose carriers and set delivery windows and loading times. The case is still pending.
Sources
- Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms, petition for a writ of certiorariSupreme Court of the United States, Jun 22
- Order List (11/16/2026)Supreme Court of the United States, Nov 16
- SCOTUS action revives shipper/receiver liability post-MontgomeryFreightWaves, Nov 17