Updated

Crashes & courts

J.B. Hunt must face negligent hiring claim at trial over fatal 2023 truck crash, Arizona judge rules

A federal judge in Arizona on Nov. 19 sent to trial a claim that J.B. Hunt, acting as a freight broker, negligently hired the carrier in a 2023 crash in which two people died and three children were badly hurt, Law360 reported. The judge rejected a bid to hold J.B. Hunt liable as the driver's statutory employer.

The ruling in the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona keeps J.B. Hunt Transport Services in the case on the negligent hiring count, according to Law360. Families of the people killed and hurt in the October 2023 crash sued J.B. Hunt, the carrier Borderlanders and the truck's driver, FreightWaves reported in August. J.B. Hunt's brokerage unit had tendered the load to Borderlanders, which hauled it as the only motor carrier, and the driver was a Borderlanders employee.

The plaintiffs claim J.B. Hunt overlooked the carrier's record of safety alerts, crashes and inspection violations, among them unsafe lane changes, ignoring traffic control devices and English proficiency. They also say J.B. Hunt led the shipper, Lincare, to believe its own trucks would move the freight. In its June motion for summary judgment, J.B. Hunt argued that its carrier agreement made Borderlanders responsible for hiring, training and dispatching its own drivers. These are claims in a civil suit, and no court has found anyone liable.

The case is one of several testing broker liability after the Supreme Court's unanimous ruling this year in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. The justices held that the federal law known as F4A does not protect brokers from state negligence claims that fall under its motor vehicle safety exception. C.H. Robinson is appealing a verdict of more than $600 million in another such case, FreightWaves reported. Law360 did not report a trial date.

Why it matters: Each broker case that reaches a jury pushes brokers to screen carriers harder on CSA alerts, crash history and English proficiency violations. Small carriers that live on brokered freight should look at their own SMS profile the way a broker's vetting team would.

Sources

More in crashes & courts