Updated

Rules & enforcement

New York non-domiciled CDL ruling: appeals court says DOT wrongly withheld $73.5 million

A federal appeals court ruled on Nov. 13 that the U.S. DOT and FMCSA acted arbitrarily when they cut $73.5 million in highway money from New York over its non-domiciled CDLs. The fight covers about 32,600 non-domiciled CDL and learner's permit holders in the state.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled unanimously for New York, FreightWaves reported. In April, DOT withheld $73,502,543, about 4% of the state's usual federal funding, after FMCSA found New York out of compliance. The agency objected that the state issued non-domiciled CDLs that stayed valid after the holder's permission to be in the U.S. ran out.

The judges noted that FMCSA itself conceded the regulations in force at the time had no rule that a CDL must expire with the driver's lawful presence documents. FMCSA called its reading common sense. The court answered that the plain text of the agency's own rule should have settled the question. According to the opinion as reported by FreightWaves, before September 2025 states did not have to match non-domiciled CDL terms to those papers, and FMCSA could not point to any earlier case in which it faulted a state on that ground.

Under the rules the court reviewed, non-domiciled applicants showed an unexpired Employment Authorization Document or a foreign passport with an approved Form I-94, and their CDLs ran five years at first issue and eight at renewal. The court counted about 32,600 such CDL and permit holders in New York, roughly 7% of the state's licenses.

The ruling deals with the funding cut and the older rules. It does not settle the federal requirements adopted since September 2025. A similar case between California and the federal government is pending at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. DOT had not said by Nov. 15 whether it would seek further review.

Why it matters: For New York non-domiciled CDL holders, the ruling removes the funding pressure tied to licenses issued under the older rules. It does not decide the newer federal requirements, so check your license term against your work papers.

Sources

More in rules & enforcement